Here are the abstracts and contact information for
the presentations made at the panels on single women
at the Canadian Historical Association Annual Meeting,
University of Toronto, Canada, May 2002.
Older Women's Reflections on Lifelong
Singlehood
Jennifer Baumbusch
Faculty of Nursing, University of Alberta
jbaumbusch [at] telus.net
Ever-single, older women are a diverse group, whose
experiences of singlehood have received little attention
from researchers. In this qualitative study, eight
women, between the ages of 65 and 77 living in a mid-sized
Southwestern Ontario city, were interviewed about
being ever-single during the latter half of the 20th
century, including their perspectives of the benefits
and drawbacks of this status during this time period.
Data were collected in semi-structured interviews
and the constant comparative method was used for data
analysis. Emergent themes illustrated how the women's
stories of singlehood were affected by the sociopolitical
contexts of their youth, which thereby influenced
the women's desire and opportunities to get married.
They also discussed how singlehood had influenced
their financial, educational, housing, and social
support resources. Upon reflection, the women articulated
the benefits of lifelong singlehood, strongly emphasizing
their independence and "ability to be alone",
which was viewed as very important as they aged. The
drawbacks of singlehood focused on loneliness and
the absence of a social support network, which took
on particular importance as the women experienced
increasing age and disability. Overall, the participants
expressed satisfaction with their marital status and
defied common stereotypes about older, single, women.
Implications of these findings relate to the social
structure of marital status and its impact upon the
lives of women who remain single.
top
Sherbourne House Club: Home for The
Girl of the New Day
Janet Forbes
Dept. of Geography, York University
janetforbes [at] stn.net
"For girls the situation is worse. They are
without protection & loneliness is liable to drive
them to seek relaxation from drab living conditions
at any cost.....I think the only solution lies in
the foundation of residential clubs....The business
men who employ clerks of both sexes, do they owe nothing
to their employees beyond the regular payment of wages?
Have they no responsibility concerning the lives these
clerks are forced to live?"
- Letter from Vincent Baseri, The News Publishing
Company of Toronto, April 9th, 1912
Young single working women moving to Toronto in the
early 1900's, found the housing situation dire, and
in response, charitable agencies built residences
for these young women. Typically these agencies oversaw
the 'moral well-being' of their residents through
the imposition of curfews and restrictive conditions.
In 1916, H. Henry Fudger, President of Simpson's Department
Store provided the Sherbourne House Club. Based on
the principal of self?governance, the rules were made
and maintained by the residents. This paper looks
at the unique experience of the Sherbourne House Club
as described in scrapbooks kept by Florence Bollert,
from 1916 though the end of WWII.
While a large number of the residents were employees
of Simpson's, the other residents found employment
in a broad range of occupations, and included writers,
musicians, social workers. The professional lives
of these single women were reflected in the activities
undertaken within the public rooms of the Club. Music
recitals, theatrical productions were held as part
of the prodigious money making programs which funded
the social welfare and health care programs for young
women that were club projects. Educational programs,
dance and card parties rounded out the house life.
If the aspiring middle class young women of Sherbourne
House Club were more likely to view the world from
the protected comfort of the sunroom than the from
exposed front porch of factory working class single
women, it was a sunroom with large open windows and
a clear view of the world passing by, not just on
the street but through the doors of the club. It was
home in Toronto for unattached women, back from Mission
work in Japan or working with travelling theatre companies.
The story of the women residents is a window into
the life of independent single women in Toronto; the
precarious nature of good health and employment, the
pleasures in friendships and city life.
The Club's membership was open to all women in Toronto
regardless of their residence. Perhaps because of
this more expansive membership, but more likely because
of its founding principles and the women who guided
the residential aspects of the club, the residence
was both a home and a site of empowerment for the
single women who lived there.
top
Mission Work and
the Single Woman: The Professionalization of British
Missions, 1865-1910
Rhonda A. Semple
Dept. of History, Calvin College (MI)
rsemple [at] calvin.edu
How the profession of 'missionary' was defined
underwent a profound change over the course of the
nineteenth century. The movement became increasingly
professional both in terms of providing a unique
service for the western community, and by creating
exclusive qualifications for joining the guild.[1]
The presence of wives and daughters in the mission
field, the first women to join the mission project,
initially reinforced traditional male spheres of
professional responsibility. However, by the 1890s
single women workers made up a significant portion
of British Protestant Mission Societies' workforce.
Their presence challenged traditional gendered definitions
of what constituted 'professional' work in several
ways. Men received education and training which
became gradually more specialized throughout this
period. For both men and women, missions paralleled
wider secular professional society in the way in
which educational requirements gradually replaced
social markers as a way of differentiating between
those deemed qualified and those unqualified for
mission life.[2]
However, an assessment of whether or not a female
candidate could be considered 'ladylike' remained
a part of the selection process of most missions
until well into the twentieth century. Thus, single
professional women offered a real challenge to mission
boards. In the hiring stage, they were expected
to meet the 'ideal' concept of a middle class 'lady';
yet that very ideal was dependant upon being marries.
This was even more true 'in the field' where the
status of being unmarried defied the both accepted
model of Christian wife and mother, and further,
the established mission tradition of hiring women
connected to the society through familial relations,
and who would soon marry into the wider mission
family. In many cases these single professionals
in fact carried on the work begun by the wives of
missionaries. However, the unmarried status of these
female workers, their ability to work longer hours
and live and work independently of a spouse or male
co-workers, resulted in the formation of a [unique/gendered]
professional identity.
This paper analyzes the hiring and employment
practices of three British Protestant Missions:
the London Missionary Society, the China Inland
Mission and the mission work of the Scottish Presbyterian
Churches. Each of these missions received benefit
from the growing number of newly professional single
women who chose careers in missions in the modern
period. However, these women's developing professional
identity required that they carefully negotiate
between what was constituted professional activity,
and personal choice. For respectable Christian women
in the long nineteenth century, marital status played
a key role in shaping their experience as British
missionaries, and in defining their profession.
1 Jeffrey
Cox (1995) "The Missionary Movement", in
Nineteenth Century English Religious Traditions: Retrospect
and Prospect (ed. D.G. Paz)(London), 197-221. back
2 Fiona Bowie, Deborah
Kirkwood and Shirley Ardener (eds.) Women and Missions:
Past and Present (Oxford).
back
top
Help Wanted - Single, White and
Female: the boundaries of wage-earning during the
Great Depression in Toronto
Katrina Srigley
Dept. of History, University of Toronto
katrina.srigley [at] utoronto.ca
An examination of women's employment experiences
during the 1930s raises some fascinating historical
questions about gender boundaries: What was it like
to be an employed woman during a period of high male
unemployment? What impact did the traditional association
between breadwinning and masculinity have on women's
experiences of wage-earning? How did prevailing white
middle-class Anglo norms define women's employment
options?
As the scholarship of Margaret Hobbs has shown the
male breadwinning ideal exerted pressure on employed
women during the 1930s. Exclamations like "Go
Home Young Women!" demanded that women had no
right to employment when men were unemployed. Despite
this concern all women were not targeted equally.
Indeed, the boundaries of gender shifted to include
and exclude employed women depending on such factors
as marital status, race/ethnicity, age and class.
Using oral history methodology and the tools of
social and cultural history, this paper asserts that
wage-earning among single white females in 1930s Toronto
was socially acceptable. In some instances, femininity
was an asset for employment rather than a liability.
It defined job options and provided single white women
with access to jobs not available to married women,
women of colour, recent immigrants, non-English speakers
and unemployed white males.
By the 1930s, gender boundaries had shifted to encourage
wage-earning among certain groups of women. Despite
these shifts, the Ontario government, business managers
and the community continued to patrol the boundaries
of women's employment: they created regulations, formed
company policies, wrote editorials and exerted social
pressure on those who didn't conform. In doing so
they maintained the façade of the male breadwinner
ideal.
top
Daughter of Zelophehad:
Margaret Bayne's Autobiography and the Framing of
the Single Self
Jenéa Tallentire
Dept. of History, University of British Columbia
jltallen [at] interchange.ubc.ca
The nearly universally prescribed, and adopted,
role for women of any class, race, or ethnicity
in Western nations through the nineteenth century
to the second World War was heterosexual marriage,
coupled with full-time domestic labour. To move
across the boundary from single to married meant
the confirmation of the central social identity
of women in Western society. Yet many women never
made that transition to the married state, through
choice or circumstance. Although the term 'single'
can imply solitude and isolation, in fact many single
women reveal lives of complex relationships, vocations,
and community ties. Allowing single women's voice
to be heard about what they thought of their state
and what opportunities and barriers they reveal
about living single is an essential part of understanding
their history.
The experience of singleness could create a distinct
identity that is different from that of a married
woman. The single woman was compelled by her marital
status to frame her identity not in terms of husband
and children, but in employment, service, and relationships
outside the conjugal home. From a close examination
of the unpublished autobiography of Margaret W.
Bayne (1865-1946), we can see multiple identities
that embrace both traditionally-prescribed arenas
for women's interests (family, relationships) and
those often preserved for men: politics, intellectual
attainment, and ambition. This paper is concerned
with demonstrating these multiple strands of Margaret
Bayne's life. As a teacher, and administrator for
the Industrial Home for Girls in Vancouver, Bayne's
career seems to have been typical of middle-class
educated single women. As a homesteader, land speculator,
and political activist, we discover that her life
was both emblematic and unique.
Her autobiographical narrative challenges us to
see her identity not only as a 'woman,' with all
that early 20th century ideology implied, but as
a self-directed, independent person. Her work helps
reframe the divide of 'woman/man' that we commonly
adopt, into a potentially more revolutionary model:
'woman/individual.' At the same time that she is
weaving a narrative of relationships, mutual help
and connection, she is firmly placing herself within
the noteworthy public events and personages of her
day. A pioneer in both the literal and political
sense, Bayne weaves a many-layered narrative that
allows us to the see her not only as a 'single woman',
but as an individual and a citizen as well.
top
"I Aimed to See all the World
I Could": Single Women as Homesteaders in the
American West
Eileen Wallis
Dept. of History, University of Utah
Evehallow [at] aol.com
From Frederick Jackson Turner forward, historians
of the United States have emphasized the significant
role played by homesteaders in settling the west.
Following the passage of the Homestead Act in 1862,
thousands of families took up the challenge of migrating
in return for free land. While some families did find
a new stake in life, many soon found isolation, idleness,
and economic hardship to be more than they could stand
and retreated east in defeat.
This vast migration coincided with the increasing
visibility of women in American society. Women who
did not marry or lost their husband were no longer
necessarily confined to the domestic world; many chose
careers or roles in reform rather than waiting quietly
at home for a (new) husband. This phenomenon led me
to wonder: how did marital status affect who chose
to move west to take advantage of the Homestead Act?
Did single women respond to the opportunity, and why
or why not? If they did, how did their marital status
affect how they understood and experienced life "holding
down a claim"? Did they encounter the same hardships
as men, or did gender shape their experience differently?
The historiography on the American West has a long
and venerable tradition, but it has focused largely
on the activities of white men. However, the last
ten years have seen increasing interest in how women
of all races and classes experienced the west. Historians
such as John Mack Faragher and Lillian Schlissel have
made substantial contributions to what we know about
married women on the Overland Trail. Susan Armitage,
Glenda Riley, and Elizabeth Jameson have all dealt
with women living and working in both the 19th and
the 20th century west.
The most valuable sources I have found are published
accounts left behind by women who lived through this
momentous period in world history. Fortunately many
are now being published, but many more remain unpublished
in archives and in family memories. I found that large
numbers of single women did indeed choose to take
up land under the Homestead and later acts. As expected,
their marital status profoundly shaped that experience,
from how shelter was built, to whether or not they
held down another job while homesteading. Interestingly,
however, these experiences were not all negative:
in many cases I found women expressing both enthusiasm
for the experience and tremendous pride in what they
accomplished. I believe understanding how marital
status affected the homesteading experience will help
return women to their proper place as one half of
the people tackling the challenges of the prairies
and the plains of the American west.
top